Wall Street is Expecting Stocks to Rise, but This May Be Too Cautious View

The famous quip by Groucho Marx, "I refuse to join any club that would have me as a member," resonates with a sentiment expressed by strategist Peter Tchir of Academy Securities. Reflecting on the prevailing market sentiment, Tchir notes his unease with how quickly certain perspectives have become mainstream.

‍

"Now that the consensus is that everything President-elect Trump does is just a starting point for his bargaining, I’m a bit concerned that the market has grown overly complacent. While we advocated for this view, it’s surprising how rapidly it has turned into a widely accepted stance," Tchir remarks.

‍

This tendency toward consensus extends to predictions about the U.S. stock market for 2025. Not a single sell-side analyst forecast anticipates a decline in the market. According to MarketWatch’s compilation, the median projection from Wall Street points to the S&P 500 climbing to 6,600, reflecting a 9% gain from current levels.

‍

Strategists from Mizuho Securities USA, led by Steven Ricchiuto, suggest that this anticipated rise would sustain price-to-earnings (P/E) ratios in the 23 to 24 range. While considered high, these levels are not deemed excessively overvalued.

‍

"This ongoing bullish outlook appears reasonable, particularly if inflation stays below 3%. Such a scenario would enable the Federal Reserve to gradually lower the federal funds rate toward 4%, aligning with the current expectations in the futures market," the Mizuho strategists observe.

‍

Interestingly, despite the projected market rise, these strategists characterize the general outlook as somewhat cautious. They highlight that the market has outperformed earnings growth over the past two years, which justifies some restraint. Furthermore, they express concern that Trump's ambitious economic policies might introduce inflationary pressures.

‍

The Mizuho team emphasizes a critical risk to financial markets in 2025: rising long-term interest rates and a potential reinversion of the yield curve at higher levels. If economic growth accelerates while the labor market remains at full employment, domestic inflation could escalate. Additionally, a weaker U.S. dollar might exacerbate inflation by reducing the deflationary effect of cheaper global goods.

‍

Recent developments, including Trump’s latest tariff threats, have triggered a mild risk-off sentiment in financial markets. U.S. stock futures edged lower, with the S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite showing slight declines. Bond yields rose, the U.S. dollar strengthened, and gold prices retreated.

‍

French stocks and bonds also came under pressure, driven by domestic political challenges. This confluence of factors underscores the fragile balance in global markets as they react to political and economic uncertainties.

‍

Asset Performance Snapshot

The S&P 500 and Nasdaq Composite have delivered strong performance year-to-date, with respective gains of 26.47% and 28.02%, reflecting optimism in equity markets. In contrast, gold has seen mixed results, rising 28.43% YTD but posting a 3.09% decline over the past month. Oil prices have struggled, declining both over the month (-4.16%) and year-to-date (-3.67%).

‍

The interplay between economic growth, labor market conditions, and monetary policy will be pivotal in shaping financial markets in 2025. While the consensus outlook remains optimistic, risks such as rising interest rates, inflationary pressures, and global trade tensions could alter the trajectory. Investors are advised to remain vigilant, balancing optimism with caution as they navigate a complex and evolving economic landscape.

‍